øAslickproductions.org/forum/index.php?PHPSESSID=5f0fck550j2m4m2fpbtkj2vkm1&action=profile;u=25;area=showposts;start=150e:/My Web Sites/Slick Productions - FFIV Message Board/slickproductions.org/forum/index7958.htmlslickproductions.org/forum/index.php?PHPSESSID=5f0fck550j2m4m2fpbtkj2vkm1&action=profile;area=showposts;u=25e:/My Web Sites/Slick Productions - FFIV Message Board/slickproductions.org/forum/index7958.html.zxC›h^ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÈ0Pd�:OKtext/htmlISO-8859-1gzip0|Ö�:ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿWed, 11 Mar 2020 08:19:39 GMT0ó°° ®0®P®€§²ð®B›h^ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ3;�: Show Posts - assassin

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - assassin

151
Game Modification Station / Re: Zozo NPCs
« on: October 21, 2016, 03:00:19 AM »
i'd tend to favor keeping a 1:1 correspondence to maintain sanity.  and i dunno how many speedrunners would play a hack in the first place; they tend to favor unaltered originals for competition purposes, and for having the whole host of bugs to exploit.

that said, as long as the ratio is consistent, a persistent player could figure it out by talking to the same clue-giver over and over and observing the game clock.

now, my hack idea wouldn't do much against anybody who's willing to lean on the common knowledge of 6:10:50, and make a beeline for the first clue-giver and/or the clock (depending on implementation).  it'd need to be combined with one of the other hack ideas to challenge these cheapos.

another issue is the game clock maxing out at 99:59:00, but let's ignore that. :/

152
Game Modification Station / Re: Zozo NPCs
« on: October 21, 2016, 02:00:22 AM »
regarding hacks, one idea (no way it's implementable) would be:

1) record your game time as of receiving the first clue.
2) have future clues (and the minute hand -yielding wall clock) get their numbers shifted by the time elapsed since.
3) have the Chainsaw clock's choices get shifted by the time elapsed since.

besides requiring SRAM and all sorts of math, some other key issues would be:
- rounding might be required, and would be eviler than the shifting.  the various clue times and choices are spaced a bit apart, but the game clock is precise to smaller increments in all 3 units.
- the "start state" of the Chain Saw clock: i think it'd be undefined if you hadn't gotten a clue yet, so you'd need to bar access to it temporarily.  or maybe expand Step #1 above to also include the first interaction with this clock?

so the "original" solution would still be 6:10:50, but the player would be responsible for the added timekeeping (e.g. noting when they received their clues in addition to what they were).

and this shifting could be stacked on top of the ideas discussed above (e.g. several times chosen from) for a special brand of hellishness. :laugh:

153
Game Modification Station / Re: Zozo NPCs
« on: October 21, 2016, 01:41:00 AM »
Quote
And IMO, only someone who doesn't know how puzzles work would even go to the Chain Saw room without knowing the solution, because otherwise they would still be getting there by...I won't say luck, because cheating seems like the more appropriate word.

i'm not sure what you mean here.  so i'll state how i see it unfolding: plenty of people would visit the chainsaw building.  they'd guess once or twice since they were already in front of the clock, and most likely fail.  then they'd narrow down clues around town, and after they couldn't find anybody else to talk to, they'd guess the remaining valid options.  since not everybody knows to "talk" to a wall clock (they don't give you information elsewhere in the game, and how many of those types hold Elixirs?), some might be going through 10 options instead of 2, but it's still manageable.


Quote
Also, that's like saying you've "completed" Super Mario 64 because you beat Bowser after finding 119 out of 120 Stars.

no, it's like saying you picked up the 120th star from a roulette wheel or a slot machine.  unless, of course, your religion prohibits you from keeping Stars acquired in evil games of chance. :P  mine does not, thank you.


Quote
yes, i'm saying that a number of school-attending kids in that age range could not immediately rattle off numbers divisible by 20.  hence my phrase "immediately discern".  some might not get it at all, and some might take a bit of time.  either way, recognizing said duplicate would require some problem solving for a portion of this age range.

Are you serious? There're only five options for the seconds; how long can it take to find the ones that are divisible by 20? If you can't do that, that's not Square's fault.

again: yes, i'm quite serious that many kids in the 8-14 age range wouldn't know what the hell somebody meant if they were asked for a bunch of numbers "divisible by N".  and that others would at least take some time to process them -- or as i put it in my first post:

Quote from: me
identifying the former clue as redundant is in and of itself a form of puzzle solving to some children

you can keep rolling your eyes at me or putting up "stfu" icons, but maybe you should go ask random 8-10 year-old kids about "divisibility" before deriding my assertion further.


Quote
the puzzle doesn't take place in isolation, but inside of a game, with a town and buildings, and a big ol' wall which will or won't move.  so the puzzle is plenty solvable in that context.  and it doesn't exist in any other context, so that is the only one that matters.

What difference does that make?! It's still a puzzle! Anyone who has to guess a puzzle's solution in order to solve it is missing the boat.

missing the boat, yet not missing the Chainsaw. :P  and that's what matters.


Quote
It sounds like you're trying to argue that the feedback to the wrong answer constitutes the "final clue" that the player needs to solve the puzzle. I'm telling you it doesn't because it's a direct result of the player trying to solve the puzzle. By that logic, even if a player was oblivious to the NPC clues, they could still use the 149 clues that they obtain from guessing the time over and over again. By that logic, if I was trying to solve a Sudoku, I really only need one "clue": the solution in the back of the book. Then I just write it in and, boom, puzzle solved. Like I just said, anyone who would solve a puzzle that way is missing the point.

it sounds like you're saying that plugging numbers into the clock is somehow analogous to flipping to the end of the Sudoku book.  it isn't.  it's not cheating.

nor are there any catastrophic results: if you put in the wrong time, the clock and building stay intact, so you can try again.  the puzzle is still active.

the clock is MEANT to take multiple inputs.

the way i see it, it's a continuum: both in time spent completing the puzzle, and inversely, in pride received from doing so.  the more guessing, the longer it takes, the more frustration and less sense of satisfaction.

in contrast, you seem to see it as an all-or-none situation: ANY element of luck in completing the puzzle somehow means the entire effort has been tainted.  the 2/150th overwhelms the 148/150th, like a droplet of cyanide in the bloodstream, and woeful fatality ensues.

154
Game Modification Station / Re: Zozo NPCs
« on: October 20, 2016, 08:12:37 PM »
Quote
So then we get into your argument about him repeating someone else's clue because he's "human". Are you saying, maybe he should've said "two" but he slipped and said "four" instead? Are we really going with the "to err is human" argument here? Would you have said the same thing if he'd said "ten", which is actually the RIGHT answer? Or, going back to the whole "separate buildings" argument, what if, instead of the seconds clue, he'd repeated one of the hours clues? Would you still believe this to be intentional?

i'm not saying he slipped.  i'm saying he told a lie without coordinating it with somebody in another building first.

as for your last question, where is he in relation to the worker line?  if he's some distance away, repeating one of their clues is more realistic to me.

Quote
Look, I can understand your point about repetition adding credence to the "they're lying" aspect of this. I would be inclined to agree with your opinion about this redundant clue -- IF it didn't leave an omission. If you want to argue that maybe the developers intended for there to be some repetition, I'd be more inclined to believe you if there were several NPCs repeating each other's clues, but...only one? And there's an omission in the clues BECAUSE of it? That tells me it's NOT an intentional repetition, it's a mistake.

no disagreement on that aspect.

Quote
But if an omission in the clues means you can't solve the puzzle without guessing, that feeling of satisfaction goes right out the window.

why?  i've still solved 148/150th of the puzzle.  only a severe pessimist would not gain satisfaction from this, and regard it the same as arriving there by pure luck.

Quote
Are you saying there are 8-14 year olds that can't do basic math? Or that can't tell time? :stfu:

(Don't bother bringing up the fact that some kids can't get a formal education, that's still no reason for them not to have this elementary-level knowledge.)

yes, i'm saying that a number of school-attending kids in that age range could not immediately rattle off numbers divisible by 20.  hence my phrase "immediately discern".  some might not get it at all, and some might take a bit of time.  either way, recognizing said duplicate would require some problem solving for a portion of this age range.

Quote
There's also a difference between making a puzzle somewhat esoteric and making it unsolvable.

the puzzle doesn't take place in isolation, but inside of a game, with a town and buildings, and a big ol' wall which will or won't move.  so the puzzle is plenty solvable in that context.  and it doesn't exist in any other context, so that is the only one that matters.


Quote
OK, you're right in the sense that puzzle books have the solutions printed and easily accessible, whereas this puzzle doesn't. But the flaw in that argument is, it's not wrong, but doing that in this game would make the puzzle way too easy. If you could purposefully enter a wrong code into the clock, and telling you it's wrong includes simultaneously giving away the right answer, then that negates the whole purpose of the NPC clues. When I'm solving a Sudoku, I don't write random numbers into the boxes and then look at the solution. Because one, there'd be no point to writing random numbers in the first place, and two, it would defeat the whole purpose of the puzzle.

yes, the differences are piling up.  all the more reason why the Sudoku analogy was feeble, and doesn't apply here. :P

but my key point there stands: in the game, the puzzle is interactive, and gives you feedback for the final coinflip.  the Sudoku puzzle in itself does not, which is why you'd need to rely on a separate answer key to iron out the final uncertainty.

155
Game Modification Station / Re: C. V. Bug-Fix Comp and C. V. Script Fix
« on: October 20, 2016, 04:59:23 PM »
recognizing the duplicate clue itself requires some reasoning that i think you're glossing over here, which is easy for someone of an advanced age and corresponding faculties to do.  8-14 year-olds were likely a good chunk of this game's target demographic.  many people in that group will not immediately discern that a hand "pointing at 4" is a subset of "divisible by 20".  so identifying the former clue as redundant is in and of itself a form of puzzle solving to some children.

thus, there can be a case of something that augments a puzzle or adds a minor twist to it, without being a necessity to complete it.

filtering out such noise wouldn't be unprecedented in puzzle solving.

if you do indeed frequent puzzle books, you'll know that in the "Person 1 doesn't live in House 2", "Person 2 is older than Person 3", "and Person 3's car is not red" -style puzzles, there will sometimes be more than the bare minimum of clues.  are you suggesting all of those cases have typos as well?  obviously, those puzzles don't have omissions, but they ALSO don't have a giant wall that moves in front of your face to tell you when you're right. :P

156
Game Modification Station / Re: C. V. Bug-Fix Comp and C. V. Script Fix
« on: October 20, 2016, 04:45:05 PM »
OK, so you don't know who your neighbour is. What does that have to do with this? Remember, everyone in Zozo, except allegedly the "this place is dangerous" guy, is a liar, and all of these people (again, with a few exceptions) mention the clock. That fact ALONE should tell you that they know about the puzzle, and that they have all conspired to tell you lies about it. OBVIOUSLY, this is an organized, coordinated system.

conga line members aside, i see it as less of a coordinated conspiracy than as individual liars.  liars whose duplicate clues are kept to a minimum due to space constraints -- the same sort of constraints that make 3 houses and 5 townspeople constitute an average "town" in this game.  no town is actually meant to be that small; the kid with the blonde hair, the lady in the red dress, the old man in the hat, the brown-haired guy in the shirt, and the old woman with the ponytail are a sampling of what's understood to be a more populated area.  sometimes, there are repeats in the sampling, and you'll get the mind-blowing occurrence of two old guys in hats in a single town.  likewise, Zozo had a repeat slip through.

i don't see redundant Zozo clues as any more of an assault on logic, no closer to a rip in the time-space continuum, than two old men in hats living in the same municipality.


Quote
How about you read the WHOLE paragraph before jumping to conclusions? My point is, if you can't expect two people in neighbouring buildings to know to give different clues, how can you expect the same from all the other thieves in separate buildings?

i don't.  which is why having some repetition seems more realistic to me.  more repetition yet would be even more realistic, but there's no rule that having one duplicate means you need to have at least two for the first to be intentional.

keep in mind that recognizing the duplicate requires a little reasoning, which i'll discuss in my next post.


Quote
uh, a big wall moves right in front of your face, making noises in the process.

THAT'S the "real-time feedback" you were referring to?! OK, yes, obviously I was aware of THAT. You made it sound like choosing a single hand correctly gave you feedback. But instead you're trying to say this is enough? In which case you just negated your own argument about the difference between this puzzle and a Sudoku! :stfu:

nope.  you're equating the Chainsaw puzzle giving you feedback with having to flip to the back of a puzzle book for Sudoku answers.  this is a flawed comparison, because the latter divulges the whole answer, while the former only tells the solver whether they plugged in the correct answer.  vastly different.

why does it matter whether the feedback occurs after a single hand?  bottom line: you have to input a whopping three numbers twice.  how hard is that to do?  how time-consuming?  if someone is that short on time, maybe they should be checking off items on a bucket list and saying heartfelt farewells to family members, rather than playing some old video game.


Quote
First of all, I don't actually solve newspaper puzzles, I buy puzzle magazines. You can probably find one at your local supermarket. These DO have the solutions printed in the back, so I can check the answer for myself. Second, even if I did have to wait a day to see the answer, I'd still be able to see it eventually, so who cares?

whatever the print medium may be, you're still at the mercy of editors supplying the correct answer -- or else you'd be perpetually wondering whether that "5 7" or "7 5" was right.  NOT the case in Zozo, where the puzzle itself will promptly tell you if you're right.


Quote
You know what, you're thinking way too much about the "realism" aspect of this. I do still contend that having someone repeating someone else's line is LESS realistic because everyone's in the know, but even if that's not the case, there are times when realism is obsolesced by fairness. If you want a shining example of this, watch this video. Obviously it's about a completely different game, and admittedly the examples given are more extreme, but it still perfectly illustrates my point.

Being an avid puzzle-solver, playing through this puzzle, gathering all the clues, narrowing down the choices as effectively as logic will allow, doing EVERYTHING RIGHT, and still being left with a guess between two choices, is unfair. I don't care that it's only two choices, it's still unfair.

we must define "fair" differently.  bringing 150 combinations down to 2 seems _extremely_ accommodating to me.  geometrically, that's a factor of 75; arithmetically, that's a reduction of 148.  you apparently consider anything short of the answer wrapped up in a big, tidy bow to be "unfair".

157
Game Modification Station / Re: C. V. Bug-Fix Comp and C. V. Script Fix
« on: October 20, 2016, 03:26:25 PM »
Quote
So what? You don't need two people telling the same lie to know it's a lie.  Just look at...I dunno...EVERY OTHER CLUE to this puzzle besides this one. Everything else that's incorrect about the answer, you only need to be told once. You already know these people are lying to you no matter what building they're in. Why should this clue be any different?

for quite literally the FOURTH time: i said the omission/redundancy makes the NPC dialogue seem a little more human and realistic, NOT that it's a needed step in the puzzle solving.

yet with THREE replies now, you've quoted me while harping that it's not necessary to solve the puzzle.  just whose words exactly are you responding to here?

Quote
It's not unrealistic! Need I remind you that these two liars, even though they're not in the same building, are in two buildings that are RIGHT NEXT to each other?

so?  i live in a building right next door to either of my neighbors, and we don't coordinate squat together.  hell, i don't even know half of their first names.  being in adjacent buildings is hardly the breathing-on-coworkers-neck level of closeness exhibited in the conga line.

Quote
Who cares?! First of all, I haven't seen OR heard anything about the environment changing when the right answer is chosen.

uh, a big wall moves right in front of your face, making noises in the process.  now i'm beginning to understand how you could make three consecutive non sequitur replies to my original point. :/

Quote
Of course you can already figure out the hour and minute hands, so maybe those will click, but without knowing the second hand, this "real-time feedback" makes no difference because the only real feedback you need is the game telling you whether you got the answer right or not.

my points are that:
- when the puzzle *itself* gives you feedback, having to go through TWO tries is hardly the onerous, gut-wrenching assault on logic and time that you make it out to be.
- your Sudoku example is invalid here, because the puzzle does not tell you when you guess wrong.  you're reliant on the newspaper editor providing you the answer at a later date.

------------

as i've said before, there's a good chance you're right about the line being botched.  i just think it's a mistake to try and extend game mechanics-level logic to dialogue, since the game is doing two things in the Zozoians' speech: 1) presenting a puzzle, and 2) giving you separate, semi-believable humanoid characters to talk to.  i also think it's a baffling mistake to repeatedly quote me and respond with lectures about certain dialogue being extraneous to puzzle solving, as i've never ONCE claimed otherwise.  truly bizarre, but if you're from a plane where walls moving doesn't register visually or auditorily, i can understand the cognitive lapses. :P

158
Game Modification Station / Re: C. V. Bug-Fix Comp and C. V. Script Fix
« on: October 20, 2016, 01:38:54 PM »
What are you talking about? If one guy says it, you already know it's a lie. So there's nothing to add by having another guy say the same thing.

i never said it added anything to the puzzle solving.  nor does it need to.  the redundancy makes them seem a bit more like authentically bullshitting individual townspeople, as opposed to mere cogs in one bullshitting machine.

Quote
And who cares about them not seeming like an organized system when they clearly already are? Those guys walking through that one hallway in a conga line each say a different hour for a reason. They have to be an organized system in order for the puzzle to be even remotely solvable.

unlike the rest of the Zozoians, the conga line members are quite close to one another (a little bit too close for mere colleagues, but that's another topic), so dialogue within the line is bound to be more coordinated.  in contrast, why should people in separate buildings have the same tight level of coordination?  it's unrealistic.

having one omission/redundancy adds in a whiff of realism.

Quote
what stone tablet was this so-called rule etched onto? :P

If you were solving a Sudoku, and the final solution came down to just one 2x2 square of numbers that could be 5 7 / 7 5 or 7 5 / 5 7, both equally valid solutions, so you choose one and then later you see the printed solution and it turns out you chose wrong, wouldn't you be pretty miffed? I've been solving puzzle magazines for years, and I have never, never, NEVER seen even one puzzle with an ambiguous solution. Why? Because they are meant to be solved purely by logic. There is NO GUESSWORK involved. The clock puzzle is no different.

it's PLENTY different, and this analogy is weak.  the Chainsaw puzzle does NOT have any ambiguous solutions, because you CAN SEE and HEAR whether surroundings change or not.  the puzzle itself gives you feedback in response to your choice, thus enabling you to adjust said choice.  in your Sudoku example, there is no real-time feedback, and thus no way to know the right answer until that week's edition of the puzzle is "over".

Quote
Maybe I should check the Japanese dialogue to be sure, maybe even the Advance dialogue, but the only way I know to do that is to actually play through the game up to that point, which I have neither the time nor the patience for just to check one line of dialogue. But even if those versions say the same thing, that doesn't make it right or fair. It could just have been one guy's mistake that no one ever realized was a mistake.

looking at Djibriel's FF6 Adv guide, the English dialogue is comparable to FF3us.  so the redundancy was likely in the original Japanese.

159
Game Modification Station / Re: C. V. Bug-Fix Comp and C. V. Script Fix
« on: October 20, 2016, 03:14:57 AM »
Quote
If the only clue one of the liars gives you is something you could infer from a clue someone else gave you, then why insert the former clue at all?

it makes the liars slightly more authentic.  they behave as individuals, rather than as some coordinated organism that "knows" not to repeat itself.

Quote
Also, yes, two options IS still a problem because it's a puzzle. Puzzles are always supposed to be solvable without having to guess AT ALL.

what stone tablet was this so-called rule etched onto? :P

if guessing were forbidden, the game should just destroy the path (or permanently lock you out of it) after one wrong answer, since there's no reason whatsoever to get it incorrect on the first try.

now, i think it's possible the dialogue was flubbed, but just haven't seen near ironclad proof here.  the townspeople can aid in the process of elimination, without wrapping up everything neatly in a bow.

out of curiosity, what does FF6j say?

160
Game Modification Station / Re: C. V. Bug-Fix Comp and C. V. Script Fix
« on: October 19, 2016, 04:11:53 PM »
having a majority or all of the puzzle be guesswork would be bad design, but making you try a whopping TWO options is hardly unfair or tedious.  as for the redundancy, it's not like the Zozoians have some Central Committee to coordinate lies; they seem a rather disorganized bunch, what with the pacing around in the rain, and passing out on the ground.

161
Game Modification Station / Re: C. V. Bug-Fix Comp and C. V. Script Fix
« on: October 19, 2016, 02:04:04 PM »
who's to say that the game didn't want to narrow it down to two choices, and leave the final coin flip up to the player?

162
Game Modification Station / Re: New patch: Status Unknown Bug fix
« on: October 18, 2016, 01:31:10 PM »

163
Game Modification Station / Re: New patch: Status Unknown Bug fix
« on: October 15, 2016, 06:51:34 PM »
^ a way i'd considered is to list possessed statuses with Scan.  it's not even a balance wrecker, but just a "tell me what you failed to convey to me with your utter absence of monster graphics (and some limitations on characters)".  and because Scan is its own command that just displays stuff sequentially, you shouldn't run into buffer size issues if/when expanding it.

the challenging part is it'd probably need a custom display command in C1, but could largely be done with a copy+paste of some other command's code.

164
Game Modification Station / Re: Leet Sketcher's Anniversary Pack
« on: October 05, 2016, 02:35:00 PM »
- http://zsnes-docs.sourceforge.net/html/gui.htm#f1_menu
- understood.  i don't consider it urgent either, but just had to get on record how bat guano the myriad resolutions are.

165
Game Modification Station / Re: Leet Sketcher's Anniversary Pack
« on: October 05, 2016, 12:55:56 PM »
is it possible to have images on your website sized at 240 * 212 (for example, or whatever they've been cropped to sans multiplier), while keeping a constant 256 * 224 size for the surrounding table cell?  that way, you'd avoid the dreaded black bars, and just have varying sizes of your beautiful orange background surrounding them?

another way would be to always do 256 * 224/223 size (i.e. raw emulator output, no cropping), and replace the black bars with transparent pixels.  but i have no idea how to do that, or what image formats support that.