øAslickproductions.org/forum/index.php?PHPSESSID=5f0fck550j2m4m2fpbtkj2vkm1&action=profile;u=33;area=showposts;start=195e:/My Web Sites/Slick Productions - FFIV Message Board/slickproductions.org/forum/indexa1c6.htmlslickproductions.org/forum/index.php?PHPSESSID=5f0fck550j2m4m2fpbtkj2vkm1&action=profile;area=showposts;u=33e:/My Web Sites/Slick Productions - FFIV Message Board/slickproductions.org/forum/indexa1c6.html.zxàFh^ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÈà•¤iÃOKtext/htmlISO-8859-1gzip@øÕiÃÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿWed, 11 Mar 2020 02:19:36 GMT0ó°° ®0®P®€§²ð®ßFh^ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÎ"ià Show Posts - Jorgur

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - Jorgur

Pages: « 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 »
196
Oh, I see, I misunderstood. I somehow thought it was possible to separate the fractional M patch and the knife fix patch, but I guess not. It does indeed seem there will have to be a number of different fractional M patches available.

197
but it's unlikely Square had Agility in that function by accident.  so imho, the best fix tries to figure out in what capacity Agility would've likely been used, while still retaining balance.
It's not quite that simple, you cannot retain balance if you include Agility. By default, in vanilla (unpatched) FF5, Knife based weapons do the exact same damage as Sword based weapons if they have the same attack power (because of the bug, knives sometimes do a little extra). It's a very simple, understandable way to calculate damage - if the weapons have the same attack power, they do the same damage. If, on the other hand, you patch the ROM to include Agility, it becomes a lot more complicated.

Take as an example a Knight wielding a Mythril Sword. You happen to find a MageMasher knife. Normally the two weapons do the exact same damage, but if half the Strength influence is replaced by Agility, the MageMasher will end up doing less damage (because Knight has low Agility).

Maybe this was intended, who knows? However, the fact remains that this is a very serious change to game balance and therefore, in my opinion, should be classified as a game modification, not a bug fix.
Quote
without an extra term in the formula, Knives are more of a poor man's Swords.  they don't really have anything to set them apart.
This is not true. According to instructrtrepe's algorithm guide, all knife based weapons halve the enemy evade stat when used. This alone gives knives an advantage over swords. Another important thing to remember is that almost any job can wield knives. Instead of buying a sword, an axe, a katana and a spear for your warrior character you can simply buy one knife.
Quote
I'm almost persuaded by the argument, but what do the damage numbers look like at each level with either approach?
With (Level*Strength)/128 + 2 (or vanilla FF5), knives do the exact same damage as swords of the same attack power. Every 3-6 levels the attacks become a bit stronger.
With (Level*Strength)/256 + (Level*Agility)/256 + 2, it depends on which job your are using:
- Knight/Samurai/Berserker/Blue Mage will do less damage with knives than with swords
- Dragoon will do a little less damage with knives
- Freelancer/Mystic Knight/Red Mage will have almost exactly the same damage with knives and swords
In a very general sense, low agility jobs will have less damage with knives and high agility jobs will have more.
Quote
I'm assuming you want a Fractional M where the Goblin Punch is fixed and Agility is not taken into account to calculate the knives damage, am I right?
Not quite, what I want is a patch that adds a fractional M system (with Goblin Punch fixed) without affecting the knife damage formula at all.
If my ROM uses (Level*Strength)/128 + 2, and I apply the patch, the formula should still be (Level*Strength)/128 + 2.
If my ROM uses (Level*Strength)/256 + (Level*Agility)/256 + 2, and I apply the patch, the formula should still be (Level*Strength)/256 + (Level*Agility)/256 + 2.

198
BTW, why do you want the Fractional / Goblin Fix but not with the knife fix, Jorgur? I'd rather have the best overall approach to just fixing the play, and wondering if I should just finish the Goblin / Knife fix.
Huh? I wasn't trying to stop you from making an overall improvement patch. I simply thought it might be useful to have a patch that simply adds a fractional M system. Why not have one of each?

Well... it seems nobody likes my approach of using the average of Strength and Agility.
It's a technically good approach as an alternative to M = (Level*Strength)/256 + (Level*Agility)/256 + 2, since you avoid the issue of damage leaps which I explained earlier.  I simply don't believe Agility should be a part of the calculation.

Uploaded.

This -should- be the Fractional M + Goblin Punch + Knife fix.

(BTW, noise, why is your ips patch larger than mine?)
Yes, this seems strange. Just to clarify, what I meant in my request was a patch that adds a fractional M system without affecting the Knife damage formula at all.

199
Much appreciated!

200
Could you guys also produce a patch that only contains the fractional M system (with Goblin Punch fixed)? It would be useful to have one around.

201
If we were to change the formula to M = (Level*Strength)/256 + (Level*Agility)/256 + 2, we would be making the game somewhat more complicated. Since Ninjas have similar Strength and Agility they would actually be no different from before. Thieves however have low strength and high agility, which means they would get an increase in damage. On the other hand, the warrior jobs have high Strength and Agility and therefore would do less damage with knives than with sword based weapons with the same attack power.

All in all, it adds a lot of complication to the damage calculation.

202
Quote
I agree again, but then the same can be said about the M = (Level*Strength)/256 + (Level*Agility)/256 + 2 approach.
Yes, that last paragraph I wrote was meant to address an issue with the M = (Level*Strength)/256 + (Level*Agility)/256 + 2 formula in general, not just your suggested variety.

Quote
Is not more complex than the "If Strength > Agility" approach.
This is very true. IMO, that patch is a lot worse in terms of changing the game balance. I see no reason why knives should be made any stronger than usual.

203
That would work, sure, but with that amount of technical alteration we are starting to look at a game modification rather than a bug fix.

Another thing that needs to be taken into consideration is that changing the formula means that increasing strength (or agility) only makes half as much of a difference for knives as increasing strength does for swords. The Brawl, Equip Swords/Axes/Katanas and Double Grip abilities wouldn't be as good when used with knife based weapons, which is a further handicap for them.

204
Jorgur: i still think your

Quote from: Jorgur
M = (Level*Strength)/256 + (Level*Agility)/256 + 2

idea from the older topic is superior.
I don't recommend that formula except when used with the fractional M system. The reason is that when this formula is used, the final damage will only increase half as often as with (Level*Strength)/128 + 2.

Example (without the fractional M patch):

Faris (Freelancer):
27 Strength
27 Agility
Wielding a Dagger

Normally this means her damage will increase every 5 levels, because 5*27=135 which is more than 128.

Now, assuming we are using M = (Level*Strength)/256 + (Level*Agility)/256 + 2
Faris' damage will only increase once every 10 levels, because 10*27 is 270 which is more than 256.

Her damage will stay exactly the same all the way until level 10 when her damage suddenly doubles (M increases from 2 to 4). This is a very serious handicap for knife based weapons, as they will be much weaker than sword based weapons between levels 5-10, 15-20 and so on. This is why I believe the only "good" formula for knives is M = (Level*Strength)/128 + 2.

Of course, if you use the fractional M system this problem disappears and you can change the formula if you want.

205
No, my IPS patch is meant for a clean, unmodified FF5 ROM. If you use the fractional M patch plus mine, you will get unpredictable results.

You will either have to manually remove the changes from a ROM patched with fractional M (then remake the IPS) or somehow remove the unwanted patching functionality from the IPS patch (I believe there are utilities for this).

206
Quote from: his algo faq
****************************
12.1) KNIVES M PARAMETER BUG
****************************

In the assembly code, it does appear that the formula for M for Knives was
meant to be:

M = (Level*Strength)/128 + (Level*Agility)/128 + 2

However, due to two lines being in the wrong order, only the first byte of
(Level*Agility) is used, instead of the whole 16-bit value.

As an example, let's say your Level is 32 and your Agility is 4.

Level * Agility = 4 * 32 = 128 = 0080h as a 16-bit number.

The first byte of 0080h is 80h = 128.

Divide by 128 = 1

Thus, Level 32 and Agility 4 gives you + 1 M

Now, use Level 32 and Agility 96:

Level * Agility = 32 * 96 = 3072 = 0C00h as a 16-bit number.

The first byte of 0C00h = 00h = 0
Divide by 128 = 0

Thus, Level 32 and Agility 96 gives you 0 bonus to M

So, since the maximum value the first byte of any 16-bit number can be
is FFh = 255, the maximum bonus to M is 255/128 = 1 (round down all fractions).

If you're interested in fixing this bug, use a Hex Editor to edit the FFV ROM
and make the following changes:

The original data at offsets:

$28313: A5
$28314: 26
$28315: C2
$28316: 20

Change these values to:

$28313: C2
$28314: 20
$28315: A5
$28316: 26

(Make a backup of your ROM, first, of course!!!!)

This will make the formula for M be:

M = (Level*Strength)/128 + (Level*Agility)/128 + 2

This change will affect any Attack type that uses the Knives Damage Parameters.
This includes Knives, Bows, Whips, Rising Sun and Full Moon, but not Maneater
or AntiMagic Bow.

Also note, that this gives a noticeable boost in power to any job that uses
those weapons.  Usernamehere from the FFV SNES Message Board has observed that
this fix makes them too powerful for his tastes.  For an alternate but more
complicated fix, you can try the following:

Original values:

$282FD-$28304: 18 69 02 00 85 0E 7B E2
$28305-$2830C: 20 AD E2 7B 85 24 AD E5
$2830D-$28314: 7B 85 25 20 F1 00 A5 26
$28315-$2831C: C2 20 20 BB 01 18 65 0E

$10308A-$103091: 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00
$103092-$103099: 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00

Change to:

$282FD-$28304: 85 0E 7B E2 20 AD E2 7B
$28305-$2830C: 85 24 AD E5 7B 85 25 20
$2830D-$28314: F1 00 C2 20 A5 26 20 BB
$28315-$2831C: 01 22 8A 2E D0 69 02 00

$10308A-$103091: 18 C5 12 B0 03 4A 80 04
$103092-$103099: 46 0F 66 0E 65 0E 18 6B

This will make the formula for M be:

If Agility > Strength, M = (Strength*Level)/256 + (Agility*Level)/128 + 2
Otherwise, M = (Strength*Level)/128 + (Agility*Level)/256 + 2
Quote from: the fractional M patch readme
FINAL FANTASY V FRACTIONAL M PATCH

System: SNES
Game ROM applied to:  Final Fantasy V (J).smc

Compatibility:  Original ROM or ROM translated with RPGE 1.10 English translation patch.  Other translations may be compatible but not guaranteed.

Contact info: instructrtrepe@hotmail.com

This .ips patch modifies the damage algorithms in FFV so that damage range increases are more "smooth".  This patch shouldn't change game balance or game difficulty.  However, small changes in Strength or Level should have a more noticeable effect on the amount of physical damage that character can do and small changes in Magic Power or Level should have a more noticeable effect on the amount of magical damage that character can do.

This patch also fixes a damage bug with knives, bows, whips, rising sun and full moon.  The formula for M is changed to:

If Strength > Agility,
M = (Strength*Level/128) + (Agility*Level/256) + 2
Otherwise,
M = (Strength*Level/256) + (Agility*Level/128) + 2

Notice how it makes Knife based weapons stronger?
My hack simply sets M = (Strength*Level/128)  + 2

207
Can you make it so the knife parameter change is optional? I never understood why that was part of the fractional M patch in the first place.

208
General Discussion / Re: Wiki thread
« on: December 14, 2014, 01:37:53 PM »
It works, but only when I use Firefox.

209
Does it have the changes to knife parameters as well?

210
Apparently it works fine to use Goblin Punch at monsters, but when monsters use Goblin Punch on your party, they do 0 damage. It seems like the monsters use the same method for calculating damage as the characters do, as far as Goblin Punch is concerned. I wonder if this problem occurs in other situations?

Pages: « 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 »