I also thought about having a party of four characters, but hadn't decided where yet. The only thing I knew for sure is that you would have a full party for the final battle. You could also chose to play as a female hero in the beginning of the game. I never drew her sprites, but I planned on her looking similar to Benjamin. The choice would've had a minor impact on your companions' dialogue and actions in a few places.
The magic targeting limitation played a role in my expansions as well. There were spells for inflicting each status effect, plus a Dia class of spells for harming undead enemies. Additionally, there were three levels to the Fire, Blizzard, Thunder, Aero, and Cure spells like normal (though I never did figure out how I was going to cram all of those in...a lot of new areas added to dungeons, entirely new dungeons, or maybe even a whole new "world" after the original game ended?). I also changed some enemy weaknesses to more traditional ones.
Also, a few character specific abilities were worked in. Tristam had throw, for example, so his primary weapons were switched to knives and katanas.

Split this off into its own topic.