Timeline of Events of the Pokémon Clover Saga
For clymax’s projects, click here. You can also follow him on YouTube, Twitter, or Retro Achievements.
Disclaimer: Any opinions expressed in each section belong strictly to the individual(s) to which the opinions are attributed in the respective section and do not necessarily reflect the views of any other individual covered in this timeline.
A. January 22 Prologue: RA Legend and Retro Olympics Event Host voiceofautumn Quits
“RA has become a corrupt shithole on the upper side of things … and … have gotten infested with powerhungry individuals.”
B. March 24 Prologue: Developer Alena Gets Claim-Sniped by Another Developer
“[The other dev] sabotaged my project and many Admins came to send me private messages just asking me to leave it alone.”
C. March 28 Prologue: RA Legend Salsa Silently Punished for Defending Developer Alena
“You are acting like an autocratic regime here.”
D. September 14 Prologue: Developer ThatAmericanSlacker Quits
“Welcome to the Dark Age of RetroAchievements.”
E. September 21 Prologue: Top-1500 Ranked Player Buraco Banned
“I was ‘BANNED’ from RetroAchievements LOL”
F. October 3 Announcement: Policy Clarification: Code of Conduct Scope
“The presence of an achievement set on our platform does not constitute endorsement for a game’s content.”
G. October 3 Reversal: An Apology to Our Community
“[The] edgy Pokémon hack … glorifies hate speech. … [W]e have no intention to ever be associated with hate speech.”
H. October 3: Administrator televandalist Resigns
“[I]t is absolutely no one’s business what other people play and people who want to make it their business can just fuck off.”
I. October 4: FBernkastelKues Removed as Developer
“[Favorite video game?] Mine’s GTA Vice City for its nuanced take on trans people.”
J. October 5: 34th-Ranked Softcore Player YoniArousement Banned
“RetroAchievements has seriously dug … their own grave.”
K. October 5: 2165th-Ranked Player CakeBananaCake Quits and Removes 2K+ RA Videos from YouTube Channel as Vowed
“I will not give any support to a site who bends the knee to a vocal minority.”
L. October 7: Former Developer JAM Responds
“[Y]ou can waste your time mastering something that eventually could be wiped out from existence.”
M. October 8: Former Developer dude1286 Responds
“Censorship is when you tell a man he can’t have a steak because a baby can’t chew it.”
N. October 8 Doubling Down: Clarifying RetroAchievements’ Goals
“RetroAchievements will not legitimize bigotry by hosting an achievement set for it. …. No direct threats [against RA staff] have been confirmed at this time….”
Site founder proceeds to leave the following comment on an outsider’s recent blog post accusing Retro Achievements of platforming “hate speech.”
Hi – I want to first say “thank-you” because this is an extremely well-written post-mortem for the events at the weekend. I’ve asked the staff to read over this as a guide to help understand the impact what has happened so far and to appreciate the effect our choices are having.
I especially appreciate the “Nobody likes taking medicine” part above. This outlines really well how we ought to deal with this. I’m planning to out a statement asap that helps govern the next steps that fits the site and the community well.
I completely agree it shouldn’t remotely take this long to say “hate speech is bad, no thanks”.
Site founder also leaves the following messages in the RA Discord:
O. October 8: Clover Achievement Developer tomojin Responds
“[T]he truth is we were both told that staff members were being threatened.”
P. October 9: Event Manager ladynadia Responds and Resigns
“[P]eople were harassed and threatened and … our highest level staff bowed and complied with what those people wanted and showed that hate will give them what they want.”
Q. October 9: Developer ChoccyMilk Responds
“I’ve also felt no desire to contribute further after seeing the recent announcements, they left a very sour taste in my mouth.”
R. October 10: 58th-Ranked Player IzaNamiZX Responds
“I would also be very interested in a community fork myself.”
S. October 10: Moderator BahamutVoid Quits After Alleged Doxxing by a Fellow Moderator Whose Identity Remains Unknown
“RetroAchievements supports openness but only when it’s convenient.”
T. October 10: Third-Ranked Player HippopotamusRex Vows to Quit
“Remind me how many points or sets do the users who recently joined and are taking over this site as the morality police have?” [Editor’s note: answer: zero, apparently.]
U. October 10: Top-600 Ranked Player Alakatrore Vows to Quit
“Never Let Narcissists Obsessed with Being Victims Infiltrate the Community as They Won’t Stop Until the Whole Thing Gets [Shut Down.]”
V. October 11: Developer NeonPug Quits
“When the ‘leader’ of said community is also willing to instantly discard the thoughts and opinions of the people who have kept the place going in an instant if it benefits him, and also willing to outright lie to [its] users, how do you act?”
W. October 11: Developer Achievess Quits
“[A]fter what happened with Bahamunt [sic], I decided to just retire and that’s it[.]”
X. October 11: Top-500 Ranked Player Wimpyfox Banned
“You betrayed your own community for some randos on bluesky, you should resign[.]”
Y. October 11: Developer ThatAmericanSlacker Clarifies His Recent Departure
“[T]he whole situation is a symptom of the leadership issues RA’s got right now.”
Z. October 12: Former Moderator BahamutVoid Provides an Update
“I am now convinced that this issue goes beyond just upper management.”
a. October 12: Former Developer Tayadaoc Quits
“To this site, which was my home for four and a half years, I say goodbye. I mourn your loss, which is now inevitable.”
b. October 14: Former Developer clymax Shadowbanned
“All Discord roles were removed with no communication or warning.”
c. October 16: Junior Developer DimensionIceDragon Quits
“I want this site will be permanently deleted because RA is the one big UNWELCOME CONCEPT.”
d. October 18: 73rd-Ranked Player Aeliana Responds
“Censorship is not the answer.”
e. October 18: Top-7500 Ranked Player Shadowwork Responds
“Never give them an inch or they will take a mile.”
f. October 19: Former Developer Kisumebuckets Responds
“A situation like Clovergate could have been predicted.”
g. October 24: FFV-Central Link Censored
“Is this the kind of community you’d want to be a part of?”
h. October 30: Wimpyfox Talks With Scott
“[By banning me just cuz I said you should resign because you get emotional and make rash decisions,] you kind of vindicated my entire comment.”
i. November 3: Achievements Launched by FFV Central, Will Support Pokémon Clover
“The work of achievement designers will stay their own.”
j. November 18: Departed Developer UnsolidSnake Responds
“I have no hope that any of this will ever be addressed.”
k. Achievement Graveyard After Clovergate
Pokémon Clover, Pokémon Periwinkle, 177, and Custer’s Revenge are now gone… but what’s next? GTA, Hong Kong ’97, and Harry Potter?
l. Reactions on Social Media
“RetroAchievements Destroyed By 🏳️🌈 Mafia”
m. Hall of Developers
Departed, Demoted, Banned, or Untracked
n. Hall of Players
Players Vocal during the Pokémon Clover Saga
o. Clovergate on Reddit
Censorship-free discussion of anything RA-related.
https://www.reddit.com/r/Clovergate
This post has been viewed 6 time(s).
Leave a Reply